Court Cases - Defence Procurement and Article 346 of the TFEU

Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU)

      Generic search

• CVRIA - Search for a case
• Association of the Councils of States and Supreme Administrative Juridictions of the EU - Search for a national decision

       Rulings

• Case 6/64 - Costa vs Ente Nazionale per l’Energia Elettrica (ENEL)
• Case 72/83 - Campus Oil Limited and others vs Minister for Industry and Energy and others 
• Case C-252/01 - Commission of the European Communities vs Kingdom of Belgium
• Case T-26/01 (Court of First Instance) - Fiocchi munizioni SpA (IT) vs Commission
• Case C-284/05, European Commission vs Republic of Finland
• Case C-294/05, European Commission vs Kingdom of Sweden
• Case C-337/05 - European Commission vs Italian Republic 
• Case C-387/05 - European Commission vs Italian Republic
• Case C-372/05 - European Commission vs Republic of Germany
• Case C-409/05 - European Commission vs Hellenic Republic
• Case C-461/05 - European Commission vs Kingdom of Denmark
• Case C-38/06 - European Commission vs Portuguese Republic
• Case C-157/06 - European Commission vs Italian Republic
• Case C-239/06 - European Commission vs Italian Republic
• Case C-246/12 P - Ellinika Nafpigia AE (EL) vs European Commission
• Case C-615/10 - Reference for a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU from the Korkein hallinto-oikeus (Finland) (Proceedings between Insinööritoimisto InsTiimi Oy and Puolustusvoimat)
• Case C-474/12 - Reference for a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU from Verwaltungsgerichtshof (Austria) (Proceedings between Schiebel Aircraft GmbH and Bundesminister für Wirtschaft, Familie und Jugend)

        Case-law indirectly related to Article 346 TFEU

• Case C-72/83 - Request for preliminary ruling by IE (Campus Oil Ltd and others vs Irish Ministry for Industry and Energy and others)
• Case C-222/84 - Request for preliminary ruling by IE (Marguerite Johnston vs Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary)
• Case C-367/89 - Request for preliminary ruling by LU (Aimé Richardt vs Les Accessoires Scientifiques SNC)
• Case C-328/92 - European Commission vs Kingdom of Spain
• Case C-324/93 - Request for preliminary ruling by UK (The Queen vs Secretary of State for the Home Department)
• Case C-273/97 - Request for preliminary ruling by UK (Angela Maria Sirdar vs The Army Board, Secretary of State for Defence)
• Case C-414/97 - European Commission vs Kingdom of Spain
• Case C-285/98 - Request for preliminary ruling by DE (Tanja Kreil vs Bundesrepublik Deutschland)
• Case C-186/01 - Request for preliminary ruling by DE (Alexander Dory vs Bundesrepublik Deutschland) 
• Case C-503/03 - European Commission vs Kingdom of Spain
• Case C-490/04 - European Commission vs Federal Republic of Germany
• Case C-141/07 - European Commission vs Federal Republic of Germany

National Courts

Belgium

• Rechtspraak (NL)
• Jurisprudence (FR)

Finland

• Market Court (EN)
• Finnish Consumer and Competition Authority (EN)

France

• LegiFrance (FR)

Italy

• Giustizia Amministrativa (IT)

Latvia

• Procurement Monitoring Bureau (LV)
• Latvian Courts Portal (LV)

Norway

• The Norwegian Complaints Board for Public Procurement (KOFA) (EN)
• Lovdata.no - Access to a collection of online legal resources (EN)
• The Courts of Norway (EN)

Poland

• The National Appeal Chamber: The Appeals Department of the Public Procurement Office arranges appeal proceeding under the Public Procurement Law and provides services, including organizational one, for the aforementioned Chamber. Also, the Appeals Department disseminate judiciary concerning public procurement and analyzes of functioning of legal protection measures. Please note that the National Appeal Chamber deals only with clams related to unlawful proceedings or omissions of action required under the Public Procurement Law. Claims related to infringement of remaining laws are tried by the Administrative Courts in Poland.

Romania

• National Council for Solving Complaints (EN)

Slovenia

• Legal Protection in Public Procurement Procedures Act (SI)

Sweden

•  Swedish courts (EN)